Aurora police defend Elijah McClain protest response to city lawmakers


AURORA | Aurora City Council members held a public conversation with Interim Police Chief Vanessa Wilson for more than three hours Tuesday, probing Aurora’s top cop on the police response to a demonstration held in honor of Elijah McClain at city hall this weekend.

Wilson and Police Commander Darin Parker explained why and when dozens of officers and sheriff’s deputies clad in tactical gear moved onto the great lawn in front of city hall, deploying batons, smoke canisters and pepper spray, during a violin vigil for McClain Saturday night.

Wilson said officers proceeded onto the lawn to break up a few dozen “agitators” who police said became increasingly aggressive and donned helmets and shields as night fell. Undercover officers dispersed among the demonstrators told Wilson: “They are talking about storming the building,” she said. Wilson said she feared demonstrators would siege or burn Aurora police headquarters, where tens of thousands of pieces of evidence are squirreled away.

“Cases and trials would be lost,” she said.

On Monday, police released a compilation of officers’ body camera footage from Saturday, which showed protestors upending a temporary barricade placed in front of the police station and officers complaining of being struck by rocks and bottles.

“A rock, solely, should not be something we should respond to with force, but when people are taking officers’ batons, trying to disarm them … and throwing things, that was very concerning to me,” Wilson said.

Police said a woman at the demonstration was handing out rocks from a backpack to hurl at officers. Protestors wielding handguns, a hammer and a lacrosse stick also raised tensions, police said.

Wilson, who is currently applying to serve as the city’s full-time chief of police, fought back tears multiple times during the call with council members, which Mayor Mike Coffman scheduled yesterday.

She said she should have communicated with numerous peaceful protestors who became ensnared in police actions as officers swept the crowd from the lawn into the parking lot amid a cacophony of violin music.

“This didn’t have to happen, and I understand your frustration,” she said at the beginning of the meeting. “I take full responsibility for Saturday.”

She again teared up after council members suggested young children were traumatized by the events.

“Those testimonials break my heart as a human being,” Wilson said.

Councilperson Juan Marcano, who attended the demonstrations for several hours, sparred with Wilson and Parker during the meeting, pressing the pair on allegations that police deployed tear gas. Police have repeatedly said no tear gas was used.

“At some point, sir, you’re just going to have to believe us,” Parker told Marcano. “I don’t know what else to tell you.”

Marcano called on the department to release all body camera footage from the event, which totals hundreds of hours of video. Wilson said the full batch of footage is forthcoming.

Police and sheriff’s deputies used their batons and pepper spray, foam rounds and three smoke canisters to disperse the crowd, officials have confirmed. Deputies from the Arapahoe County, Adams County and Jefferson County Sheriff’s Offices assisted Aurora police.

Dozens of residents and activists have condemned the police response at the event, with more than 100 public comments submitted prior to and during the meeting, the vast majority of which lambasted the department’s actions.

“It was the most ridiculous militarized over-reaction I’ve ever seen,” the McClain family’s attorney, Mari Newman, said Tuesday. Newman said McClain’s sisters, ages 22 and 17, were “devastated” that the vigil scheduled in honor of their brother was disrupted by police.

The public meeting began moments after the local U.S. Attorney’s Office and the Denver Division of the FBI announced that both federal agencies and the Department of Justice have been investigating McClain’s death for several months in preparation for a possible civil rights claim.

The federal authorities said they’re also looking into several officers recently placed on leave after it was discovered they posed for photos in the area on Billings Street where McClain was detained on Aug. 24, 2019. McClain, who was unarmed and never suspected of a specific crime, died six days later.

The three officers who stopped McClain after a man called 911 to report him as “suspicious,” have since been re-assigned, but never faced criminal charges related to the incident. The Adams County District Attorney said he couldn’t meet the necessary thresholds needed to net a conviction.

A slew of new investigations into McClain’s death have been announced in recent weeks, including one led by the city and another initiated by state Attorney General Phil Weiser.

An internal affairs investigation into the photo scandal is complete, although Wilson has yet to announce any disciplinary actions against the officers. The timeline regarding when Wilson’s findings will be released remains ambiguous and could be further stymied if the involved officers appeal any of her decisions. Officers have 10 days to appeal any decision Wilson makes with the Cvil Service Commission, which could then move forward with months of its own investigations and considerations.

Council members took no formal action during the meeting Tuesday.

Past Sentinel Colorado Coverage of Elijah McClain:

• PERRY: Aurora police used tear gas during Elijah McClain protest and cried foul about that reality

• Polis orders special prosecutor to reinvestigate death of Elijah McClain

• Tens of thousands of calls to re-examine Elijah McClain death inundate Aurora agencies

• PERRY: Only we can decide if it was wrong for police and medics to kill Elijah McClain

• Elijah McClain tragedy, illustration and anger ripples across social media

• Aurora axes contract with former state trooper hired to reinvestigate death of Elijah McClain

• Aurora lawmakers demand new Elijah McClain death query; chief mandates new police procedures

• AURORA POLICE PANEL: Cops acted properly in scuffle leading to the death of Elijah…

• Protestors, attorney condemn Aurora police treatment of Elijah McClain case

• Adams County DA: No criminal charges against Aurora police, medics in death of Elijah…

• CORONER: Cause of Elijah McClain death unclear; homicide by Aurora police not ruled out

• Protesters shut down Aurora City Council meeting over officer-involved death of Elijah McClain

• UNLIKELY SUSPECT: Those who knew Elijah balk at Aurora police account of his death

• 4 finalists for Aurora police chief make their case at public forum

• Aurora lawmakers slated to impanel police review task force Monday

• Polis signs broad Colorado police reform bill: ‘black — lives — matter’

• Aurora introduces ban on police carotid control holds, solidifying recent policy changes

• After nixing police union rep, Aurora lawmakers create new task force scrutinizing cops

• Colorado House advances police reform measure after emotional debate

• Police brutality and racism protestors face Aurora: ‘America, you owe black people’

• THE COLOR OF BLACK AND WHITE: Aurora area officials and residents offer paths out…

• Aurora eyes new contract as body camera conversation amps up

• State lawmakers, impacted Aurora families announce police oversight bill

• EDITORIAL: Blacks will be killed, abused by police until voters elect and force leaders…

• Aurora police chief fields questions about shootings, body cams and officer conduct

• Aurora lawmakers approve task force to study police controversies

• SEARCH WARRANTED: Amid turmoil, Aurora seeks a new police chief

• Aurora lawmakers give first OK to police review task force

• AURORA’S NEXT TOP COP: Residents outline qualities desired in next police chief

• Feds grant Aurora police $850K over 3 years to offset expected body camera price…

• INDEPENDENT INQUIRY: Aurora leaders, residents discuss police oversight following officer-involved deaths

• Aurora lawmakers give first OK to police review task force

• PERRY: Aurora Police torch the last of their credibility with another Friday night ‘bomb-fire’

• Aurora City Council faction dons pro-police shirts but dodges another protest

• PERRY: Aurora city council cop-shirt pranksters look like heartless brats

• EDITORIAL: Don’t undermine Aurora public meetings by hiding — arrest illegal disrupters

• TOWN HALL: Residents, elected officials push for Aurora police shooting, force transparency, oversight

• POLICE INVOLVED DEATH: Aurora first responders injected ketamine 17 times in 2019, records show

• Aurora police release scant details on spate of lethal, injurious interactions between officers and…

• PERRY: Dancing around officer-involved deaths and shootings, Aurora police shoot at their own feet

• Aurora police schedule press conference to address recent deaths related to officer-interactions

• Family of man who died after Aurora police encounter say it was ‘cold-blooded murder’

• PERRY: Stop letting police control the information about the people they kill

• Aurora police release few details on masked man who momentarily lost pulse following ‘struggle’…

• EDITORIAL: Colorado protesters, leaders deserve praise for historic police reform feats — which are…

• PERRY: Racism and pandemic crises brings out the good, the bad and the smugly…