Shooting scene near East 6th Avenue and Sable Boulevard in Aurora. 1 person was shot and a suspect is at large at about 1 p.m. Monday, according to Aurora police.
Sentinel File Photo of a 2019 shooting scene near East 6th Avenue and Sable Boulevard in Aurora.

Mainers, residents of a state only less strange than Colorado, have figured out a way to reduce the state’s divorce rate nearly by half —  they cut back on eating margarine. 

And that’s kind of why crime has fallen so much in Aurora, too, if you follow some Aurora police logic.

In 2000, the Maine divorce rate was 5.0% of all marriages. By 2009, the divorce rate in Maine dropped to 4.1%. At the same time, and at almost the identical rate, the consumption of margarine by Mainers fell from 8.2 pounds per Mainer to 4.1 pounds.

Less margarine. Less divorce.

While scientists would spit out their coffee reading this with two lungs full of scoff, Aurora Police Chief Todd Chamberlain might see that restricting how much Blue Bonnet you put on it makes for happier homes.

Chamberlain is much like President Donald Trump and his fabulous administration of keen experts who have repeatedly made clear that an amazing, nationwide substantive drop in all kinds of crime is due to Trump policy changes enacted from Day One of his second tenure in the White House.

Real experts? Not so much.

Likewise, Chamberlain, this week, says the Aurora Police Department is taking credit for a drop in property and violent crime rates in Aurora.

“We have without question systematically and strategically changed the processes, the policies, the procedures to support a 21st-Century law enforcement organization,” Chamberlain told city lawmakers last week in a council committee session. “These numbers reflect that. These numbers truly reflect the narrative of what this department is doing in collaboration with the community and what we look forward to continuing to do.”

They may “reflect” APD goals, but did they cause the change?

Experts across the country say no. Chamberlain thinks experts are “uneducated.”

“I know a lot of people think, and I’ve heard this quite often, well, ‘crime is down everywhere, crime is down across the board’ and that’s really an uneducated view and it’s an uneducated statement to make because it’s not down everywhere,” Chamberlain said.

I’m not sure if the chief loves him some margarine, but he sure doesn’t have a taste for science.

First off, he’s disingenuously wrong in saying that crime isn’t down “everywhere.” That’s misleading. While crime is down so stunningly across almost every single large and small city in the nation, and across Colorado, to the point that it’s grabbed headlines for months, it’s true that in very few places, it hasn’t fallen as much.

But if you’re like Chamberlain and dismissive of what you read in the paper, read it yourself on websites for the FBI, the Colorado Department of Public Safety and endless universities that have dived into the phenomenon.

Most of what I refer to as experts — people with things like PhDs who study this stuff and publish research and papers that are scrutinized for accuracy and then given gold stars or not — agree that it doesn’t appear to be just one thing that’s responsible for the drop in violent and property crimes, but two or three things.

“The historic reduction seen in a number of cities around the country is likely to be multifactorial,” Dr. Ruth Abaya said in an interview with other crime experts conducted by the Council on Criminal Justice in January. “One likely contribution includes significant investments in community violence intervention strategies that several of these jurisdictions have made since violence surged in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic.”

Abaya is an MD, a professor, collects degrees like my daughter collects Labubus, and is pretty educated.

“Given that in some cities violence has dropped beyond pre-pandemic levels to historic lows, it appears that recovery from the pandemic, while it might have contributed, is unlikely to be the only significant factor.”

Another expert on the nationwide phenomenon clearly points to issues that aren’t parochial. 

“The consistency of the homicide decline, both across cities and over time, makes me inclined to think this has to do with larger social movements, temporarily disrupted by COVID-19 when the world turned upside down, than with any one particular thing one particular city might be doing,” said Emily Owens, who’s the Deans’ Professor of Criminology and Economics at the University of California, Irvine, and a visiting professor at the London School of Economics.

More?

“What makes the homicide decline big news is that it was not just a local trend, but a national one, implying that the forces contributing to falling crime rates in America are national in scope,” said Alexis Piquero, chairperson of the Department of Sociology and Criminology at the University of Miami and a past director of the Federal Bureau of Justice Statistics.

Dismissing the long human battle to understand the difference between causation and correlation is convenient but problematic, and sometimes dangerous.

For those who took science in high school and college, John Snow probably comes to mind, among others.

His investigation into an 1854 London cholera crisis is a legendary tutorial.

At the time, people blamed the infection of cholera on bad air. Snow dug in and mapped out cholera infections did what we now call “research.” He discovered that it wasn’t the air in a part of London causing the infections; it was a community water pump handle. He persuaded officials to get rid of the pump handle, and the cholera infections stopped.

The “bad air” assertion is classic “cum hoc ergo propter hoc” —  “with this, therefore because of this,” referring to the Latin explanation that because you see two things moving at the same time, it doesn’t prove one causes the other. 

Most importantly, so much intellectual margarine can blind people from digging into what really might be effective in reducing crime, and repeating it or expanding on it. 

It could be that Flock cameras, or increased patrols, or more coffee for cops in squad cars late at night are linked to keeping people from shooting each other or stealing bikes from garages. But unless we know the facts, making the graveyard shift drink even more coffee does no good and keeps Aurora from further reducing crime by overlooking something that really does move the needle, like community programs that interest kids in something other than finding guns and then something to do with them.

But you’ve got to have proof, not just harsh words and swagger.

You can’t overlook the fact that even the politically conservative Common Sense Institute in Colorado made it clear last year, with charts and graphs you can’t ignore, that property crime has fallen across the state, and across the metro area, at almost the same identical rates in places that don’t even know or care that Aurora and Chamberlain exist.

Tough talk and foot patrols at the Gardens On Havana did not drive shoplifting down in Thornton. More Flock cameras on Havana Street did not drop the number of shootings in Lakewood.

Demanding good science isn’t “uneducated,” it’s how humanity moves ahead.

Follow @EditorDavePerry on BlueSky, Threads, Mastodon, Twitter and Facebook or reach him at 303-750-7555 or dperry@SentinelColorado.com

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *