AURORA | Three finalists for the manager of the newly created Office of Public Safety Accountability met with community members at a Monday meet and greet, offering a variety of experience and all talking about community trust.
John Hummel, Shenandoah Titus and Eric Williams are the finalists to lead the independent division that will act as oversight for the city’s police, fire, detention and 911 departments. The candidates interviewed with the media and then spoke with a couple dozen residents on Monday evening at the Aurora Central Library.
City officials said they hope to have the new manager in place by January, with City Manager Jason Batchelor saying he feels all three candidates are strong and it will be a tough decision.
The manager of the Office of Public Safety Accountability will be a civilian oversight role that will monitor and review complaint investigations, critical incidents, public safety policies and systemic trends involving public safety personnel. The office will take over oversight from the city’s contracted consent decree monitor, IntegrAssure.
Aurora was put under a consent decree by Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser in 2021, which mandated numerous public safety reforms regarding biased policing, excessive use of force and transparency concerns. The consent decree was the result of a state investigation into the city’s public safety departments following the 2019 death of Elijah McClain.
The most recent consent decree monitoring report found that the city is in substantial compliance with a majority of the mandates and on track to complete the recommendations in spring 2027.
John Hummel
Hummel is an attorney with Franklin D. Azar and Associates in Denver who has practiced in Colorado since 2023 and previously served as the elected district attorney for Deschutes County in Bend, Oregon. Hummel received his law degree from the University of Arkansas and has a Master’s degree in international public policy from Johns Hopkins University and Bachelor’s degrees in political science and criminal justice from Roanoke College.
Hummel’s bio says he started his career representing migrant farm workers from Mexico and unemployed loggers in rural Oregon. As district attorney, he “personally handled officer involved use-of-force investigations and criminal allegations against peace officers.”
Hummel said he views the office’s main job as restoring trust between the community and the police department, which will take time and consistency.
“The worst thing a government official can do is try to silence (someone),” he said. “They want something from you and if you can’t give them what they want, that’s going to be hard enough. Then, if you don’t listen, see them, hear them, meet them where they are and empathize with them, they rightfully will feel hurt and angry and lash out.”
Another priority Hummel identified is continuing the work of the city’s contracted monitor, IntegrAssure. It’s important to view the transition from a state-imposed monitor to a full-time city office as a beginning not an end, Hummel said.
“Improving policing is a constant process and an iterative process,” he said. “I believe in the consent decree, I like what has been achieved by the consent decree, so now, let’s build on it.”
As the only white candidate, Hummel said he feels representation matters, so he encouraged the city manager to hire one of the other candidates.
“If you’re going to hire a white man, there’s no one better than me,” he said. “But it matters when a person of color looks at this position and needs to feel that they are seen and heard.”
Shennandoah Titus
Titus is the founder and chief counsel of Police Oversight USA, a national consulting office on public safety oversight and accountability. Titus has served as human rights director for Amherst and Somerville in Massachusetts and as the director of police and community partnerships for the Boston transit police.
Titus received his law degree from Western New England University and he has several other degrees, including a Bachelor’s and Masters of Professional Studies from Cornell University. Titus’ bio says he has “over two decades of experience in investigations and oversight leadership at the municipal, state and federal level.”
Titus said his experience starting up oversight offices at the local, state and federal level has given him familiarity with addressing public safety accountability issues, such as a loss of community trust. He said his approach to communication includes managing expectations, noting the office is “no one’s avenger.”
“I’ll be meeting with community leaders to educate them on what this office is, what this office is not, what this office can do and what this office appropriately should not be attempting to do,” he said. “Once you manage expectations, it won’t make you friends everywhere, but reasonable people will appreciate the fact that they do not feel betrayed.”
Titus commended the ordinance that created the accountability office for mandating independence and requiring the city’s public safety departments to give the office full access to data and personnel during investigations.
Although Titus said he watched council meetings to learn more about the community concerns, he intentionally has not researched the public safety heads, such as Police Chief Todd Chamberlain, to avoid being influenced before making his own conclusions.
“If there are public safety officials in the city of Aurora who are not taking care of the civil and human rights of all persons within the city, then they are going to have problems with the PSA manager,” he said. “But until that time comes, I am entering this position with a clear mind and pure heart to do right by the people.”
If selected as manager, Titus said his first steps would be engaging with the community and public safety departments, as well as setting up the operating procedures of the office.
Eric Williams
Williams is the deputy vice president of investigations for the U.S. Center for SafeSport, a Denver-based nonprofit that works to reduce sexual abuse of youth athletes in Olympic Sports. He previously worked as deputy director of Denver’s Department of Public Safety and for the Federal Bureau of Investigation, where his bio says he conducted civil rights and public corruption investigations.
Williams is an attorney and U.S. Navy veteran. He received his law degree from the University of Colorado, as well as Bachelor’s degrees in criminology and political science from Metropolitan State University of Denver.
Williams, a resident of Aurora since 2018, said he thinks the city’s public safety departments have made “some tremendous missteps,” citing the death of Elijah McClain, but also noted progress has been made regarding the consent decree mandates. He specifically called out the steps the police department has taken to reduce use of force incidents and address bias.
“These are areas of focus that you’re not going to cure overnight because it’s rooted in a culture shift that is needed,” he said. “So while I think there are some pretty positive steps that have been taken, sustainability is the key.”
When it comes to helping repair trust, Williams said he plans to directly engage community members and would prioritize a listening tour with the community and public safety departments to understand the challenges and concerns.
“I would be absolutely invested in hearing from different constituencies, hearing from them, learning about their concerns and making sure I’m taking in all of that information and synthesizing it,” he said.
The biggest challenge for the office is that it’s new and still being created, Williams said. He added that whether the office has enough teeth when it comes to enforcement is “to be determined.”
Community feedback
A couple dozen residents attended the meet and greet, which allowed for informal conversations with the candidates. One theme that came up continuously was a desire to see the office make real change and enforce consequences for violations.
“I want to see action, but what I’m looking for tonight is assurance that they will hold cops accountable when they commit crimes,” Cassandra Heil, a member of the Denver Aurora Community Action Committee, said. “I want them to stand with the people and publicly scrutinize (police).”
Heil said the new manager’s commitment to community meetings will be key to rebuilding trust.
Aurora resident Megan Hankins said she wants the candidates to know that the community “doesn’t want to be adversarial.”
“We don’t want this strife, we want to be able to call on our police and feel like they will treat us with respect,” Hankins said.
On Tuesday, the Epitome of Black Excellence, an accountability activist group, said in a press release that the organization, and the family members impacted by police violence it represents, support Williams for the manager position.
The group cited several factors for their decision, including Williams’ personal connection to Aurora, his experience, his plan to partner with the community and his “desire to contribute to the community’s healing process.”
“The families are recommending an individual, not issuing a certificate of approval to the City of Aurora,” MiDian Shofner, founder of the Epitome of Black Excellence, said in the release. “Their participation does not mean that public trust has been restored.”
Shofner added that the organization will continue to review the office’s performance as it is created and encouraged the city to equip the office with the appropriate resources.
“The measure of this office will not be how many reports it produces, how many meetings it hosts, or how often the word ‘transparency’ appears in its communications. The measure will be whether its work produces meaningful changes in institutional conduct, prevents future harm, and holds those responsible accountable,” Shofner said.
The city posted the candidate interviews to its Youtube channel and is taking feedback online at EngageAurora.org/AccountabilityManager through Nov. 23.




