DENVER | A former Loveland police officer shown on body camera video roughly arresting a 73-year-old woman with dementia and later seen joking about it with colleagues pleaded guilty to assault Wednesday in a plea deal opposed by the woman’s family.
Austin Hopp faces up to eight years in prison when he’s sentenced in May for second-degree assault, although the judge also has the discretion to sentence him to probation or a halfway house. He had faced a mandatory prison sentence of between 10 and 32 years under an original, more serious assault count he was charged with.
Hopp arrested Karen Garner in 2020 after she left a store without paying for about $14 worth of items in Loveland. Police body camera video shows that after she turned away from him, he grabbed her arm and pushed her to the ground, still holding the wildflowers she had been picking as she walked through a field.
The footage shows that when Hopp had Garner pushed against the hood of his car, she tried to turn around and repeated that she was trying to go home. He then pushed her back against the car and moved her bent left arm up near her head, holding it, saying, “Are you finished? Are you finished? We don’t play this game.”
A federal lawsuit that Garner filed claimed he dislocated her shoulder. The city settled the lawsuit for $3 million, money which her family said will pay for the around-the-clock care she has needed after her condition deteriorated following her arrest.
Speaking on behalf of Garner’s extended family, Garner’s daughter-in-law Shannon Steward told Judge Michelle Brinegar that the family never wanted a plea deal, which she said tend to be used when there is a lack of evidence or an inability to prove a case.
She noted the entire arrest and its aftermath was captured on video, including police station surveillance video in which Hopp and others talk about the arrest as they watch the body camera footage, sometimes laughing or joking about it. At one point, she said Hopp told the others to listen for the “pop” during the part of footage when Garner’s shoulder was allegedly dislocated.
Assistant District Attorney Matthew Maillaro said the plea deal had nothing to do with whether prosecutors could prove their case but was the result of multiple factors, including whether there should be a mandatory prison sentence or whether the court should decide the sentence.
“This is not sweeping this under the rug,” he said.
Brinegar said pleas are offered in most cases, and she accepted Hopp’s.
Hopp had also been charged with attempting to influence a public servant, a felony, and official misconduct, a misdemeanor. Those charges were not included in the plea deal.
Another officer who arrived to help Hopp after Garner was handcuffed was charged with failing to stop or report his actions and official misconduct, all misdemeanors. Daria Jalali’s lawyer told a judge Tuesday that she was in discussions with prosecutors on a possible resolution to her case, the Loveland Reporter-Herald reported.



Unfortunate as the injuries to her may have been, this was not criminal. People have had arms broken and dislocated many times while struggling with police officers. When trying to control someone, especially a woman who is often very flexible, it is very difficult to control without injuring. Officers hate to struggle with women for these reasons. It is impossible to to know ahead of time what the person’s flexibility or physical health is. Further, it is necessary to handcuff them to keep them from injuring themselves or an officer. Usually, the injuries are caused by their own struggles against the control technique being applied. For the other officers, it appears that the force is necessary to control the person. So, to second guess those officers, is unfair. They were not beating the woman. The video shows that their intent was to control. When officers are to be prosecuted after using accepted control techniques that injure because of the other person’s struggle, we have a problem. The legislature passed an absurd, poorly worded, vague police reform bill that makes use of force an area of total uncertainty. Couple that with judgments by the uninformed media and public, and we have even more of a problem. The police can’t guess at everyone’s personal situation and not use any force when suspects walk away. That is, however, where we are. Do not be surprised when the police simply let suspects walk away or do not get involved at all. The police cannot do their job in the present state of hysteria. There are three types of excessive force. They are perceived, unintentional, and intentional. Perceived is what is common for the public and the media because they know nothing about use of force and have never had to physically restrain someone who is struggling while also trying not to injure them. Unintentional is when the officer is trying to come out on top and uses too much force due to a lack of training. Those officers need to receive more training and whatever corrective action is deemed appropriate by the agency. By the way, officers are poorly trained. Everyone is lying when they say they are well trained. Generally, they receive about half of the needed training before they go out on the street. The last type of excessive force is intentional. Those officers should be fired and prosecuted. It should be noted that the officer first said that he expressed dismay at the sound of the woman’s shoulder popping. Popping noises often happen even when there is no injury. The fact that the officer laughed at the video as they watched it, goes to human nature and the fact that all of us find humor in our jobs at things that we should not. If everything you said at work was recorded, you might be out of a job. I have been around medical people and police and fire for many years. The humor expressed is often dark and a way of dealing with the absurdities and ugly things you see. I know that you just want sensitive boy scouts doing police work, but sterner stuff is needed to be a police officer. It is unfortunate that a woman with dementia was injured. Maybe, we should accept that she and her family have some responsibility in the matter. Officers are often forced to injure or kill those who are mentally ill. Often, people are on drugs, are diabetic, epileptic or otherwise incapacitated. Even medical people cannot quickly diagnose these problems and certainly can’t talk to the person fast enough to avoid use of force. You can’t talk to someone who is walking away from you or attacking you. Officers certainly should try but there is a point where we have to accept that some people will be injured who won’t give officers the chance to talk. It is wonderful that we are going to expand the opportunity for mental health people to deal with people on the street. It is not something that law enforcement ever wanted to do. It happened because legislators looked at it as a cheap way to do things. So, while you are celebrating this plea by the officer, understand that he knew the hysteria that he was facing.
You sound very low IQ. The fact that you support this officer is a testament to that. What a pathetic bootlicker.
Jail time? maybe not. Loss of POST yes. He should lose the ability to be a LEO anywhere anytime for sure. He needs a new line of work. The family actually has won this one. The country needs a national law to prevent these LEO’s from continuing LEO employment anywhere, once they are adjudicated guilty of malfeasance in office.